• Home
  • COMMUNITY
    • NEW YORK
    • NEW JERSEY
    • CHICAGO
    • EAST COAST
    • WEST COAST
    • MID WEST
  • IMMIGRATION
  • CRIME
  • OPINION
  • INDIA
    • POLITICS
    • BUSINESS
  • FILM
    • CINEMA
    • MUSIC
  • U.S. NEWS
    • POLITICS
    • BUSINESS
    • LIFESTYLE
    • PEOPLE
  • BUSINESS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • SPORTS
  • 360
  • Classifieds
  • Videos
Search
Tuesday, July 8, 2025
  • News India Times
  • DesiTalk in New York
  • DesiTalk in Chicago
  • Post Classified Ads
  • Classifieds
  • US India Global Review
  • Gujarat Times
  • About Us
News India Times
News India Times News India Times
  • Home
  • COMMUNITY
    • NEW YORK
    • NEW JERSEY
    • CHICAGO
    • EAST COAST
    • WEST COAST
    • MID WEST
  • IMMIGRATION
  • CRIME
  • OPINION
  • INDIA
    • POLITICS
    • BUSINESS
  • FILM
    • CINEMA
    • MUSIC
  • U.S. NEWS
    • POLITICS
    • BUSINESS
    • LIFESTYLE
    • PEOPLE
  • BUSINESS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • SPORTS
  • 360
  • Classifieds
  • Videos
Home 360 Why your flexible savings account is not the benefit it could be
  • 360
  • BREAKING NEWS
  • Breaking Views
  • U.S. AFFAIRS
  • BUSINESS
  • Education
  • OPINION
  • TOP STORIES

Why your flexible savings account is not the benefit it could be

By
Pamela Herd,Donald Moynihan, Special To The Washington Post
-
December 26, 2022
0
- ADVERTISEMENT -
Share

It’s the end of the year, the season when families spend more time with loved ones … and with their flexible savings accounts. For example, the two of us just spent a good part of a day online and on the phone submitting claims for our daughter’s orthodontia bill and some mundane prescriptions.

But with the new year deadline approaching, many people are trying to use up the money they diverted to their FSAs during 2022 by splurging on spare eyeglasses, electronic massagers, first aid kits and other vaguely medical knickknacks they don’t really need. There’s a whole mini-industry of online stores specializing in FSA-approved items. The perversity of such last-minute ill-targeted health-care spending is only the tip of the iceberg: By one estimate, consumers lost $4.2 billion in unspent FSA funds in 2020.

We’re both professors of public policy who study the administrative burdens people encounter in government programs – and yet we have struggled so much with our own family’s FSA that we decided to look under the hood. What we’ve concluded is that it’s time to reevaluate the value of FSAs.

- ADVERTISEMENT -

Here is how they’re supposed to work, whether for health- or child-care expenditures. You predict your expenses for the coming year, and your employer lets you set aside some money for those expenses from every paycheck. This reduces your taxable income, and if you Google “FSA,” most hits will present it as a savvy way to save some money.

But if you don’t spend all of the money you set aside by the year-end deadline, you lose it – and that leftover money reverts to the employers. (They have a variety of options for what they do with it, including paying for the FSA’s administrative costs, reducing future employee FSA costs or, in some cases, keeping the money.)

As Vox Media’s Ian Millhiser put it: “Every year you have to guess how much money you’ll spend on health care. Guess right, you get a modest tax break; guess wrong, you light your money on fire.”

But in practical terms, the real issue is that FSAs waste a lot of user time and money.

How much money? Definitive estimates are hard to come by. The government doesn’t track these expenditures at the individual level, and the private firms that administer the FSA don’t have to report data. For what it’s worth, one analysis by Money magazine estimated that almost half the 21.6 million Americans with FSAs forfeited money in 2020, with an average loss of $408.

The administrative burdens involved are also a time tax on users. Workers typically set up an account through their employer with a private FSA vendor who assesses whether their expenses qualify. Submitting an expense request often involves a lot of photocopying, scanning and uploading receipts. You have to know what is allowed and what is not, and which form to submit. If your insurance company is involved, you can’t claim reimbursement until it has paid its share. Claims can be rejected for seemingly mystifying reasons, with little avenue for redress. If your employer changes your FSA provider, you have to learn a new set of procedures. Few of us who are not professional health-service administrators have the skills, discipline, organization and time to do this effectively.

In public policy terms, the most obvious policy drawback to FSAs is that they are a regressive benefit. It’s largely salaried employees with higher incomes who benefit from them, and the value of the tax deduction increases as you enter a higher tax bracket. This reflects a general problem with policymaking – we rely too much on tax deductions rather than direct benefits. The use of such deductions has to be monitored – generally, in this case, by the private FSA vendors, who are the reliable winners in this whole process.

It’s all a lot more complicated than it has to be, and a lot less beneficial to the American families FSAs are supposed to help. Policymakers need to break the habit of favoring complexity over simplicity. Politically it might be easier to gain bipartisan support for tax deductions rather than direct spending, but such policy solutions systematically underestimate the hassles involved, and undervalue the time we spend clawing our money back from private financial firms.

Meanwhile, back at our house, we discovered that our employers have extended the new year’s deadline by two and a half months – so we’re still hoping to get our last-minute expenses processed. Fingers crossed.

– – –

Pamela Herd and Donald P. Moynihan are professors at the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown University.

Related posts:

Public Health in Kalahandi: A Brief Overview ‘Troubling Survival: Mounting Resistance’ 5 Tips to Save on Your Small Business Taxes Tax tips & tricks that could save you thousands GOP proposes deep tax cuts, provides few details on how to pay for them
Previous articleBrooklyn Raga Massive gears up for more activities in 2023
Next articleLifestyle: Want to drink less in 2023? These habit-tracking apps can help
Ela Dutt

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Advice column: Ask Sahaj- I’ve never felt worthy of love or attention. How can I start?

Ask Sahaj: ‘I want to be with the person I love, but I can’t bear the shame.’

Money20/20: Fintech Leaders Meet for the Future of Finance








HOT NEWS

US, India push for trade pact after Trump strikes deal with...

July 2, 2025

BRICS tariff to be applied only if they adopt policies deemed...

July 7, 2025

Immigration lawyers criticize Justice Department push to pull citizenship

July 4, 2025

Health Camp of New Jersey to Host Free Community Health Fairs...

July 3, 2025


News India Times
ABOUT US

Parikh Worldwide Media is the largest Indian-American publishing group in the United States. The group publishes five periodicals – “News India Times,” a national weekly newspaper; “Desi Talk in New York,” a weekly newspaper serving the New York-New Jersey-Connecticut region; and “Desi Talk in Chicago,” a weekly newspaper serving the Greater Chicago area and the Midwestern states; and “The Indian American,” a national online quarterly feature magazine, and the Gujarat Times, a Gujarati language weekly. The combined circulation and readership of these publications make the media group the most influential in the ethnic Indian market.

FOLLOW US
© 2018, ↑ News India Times
WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com